Black Parenting or Trauma? Corporal Punishment, Discipline & the Cycle We Ignore
When does discipline cross into trauma? In this episode of In The Black Podcast, Big O, Big El, and Krush argue that corporal punishment becomes harmful the moment it stops teaching and starts conditioning fear. Reacting to two viral videos — a father beating his son on Instagram Live and a young girl taken to a police station to be “scared straight” — they unpack the line between discipline and abuse, why hitting children is the one form of violence society still excuses, and how those early lessons shape Black masculinity, resentment, and the way we handle conflict as adults.
What We Covered
The conversation opens with two moments that lit up social media: a father who filmed himself beating his son over phone and Instagram use, and a family who took a young Black girl to a police station to frighten her into behaving. Big O, Big El, and Krush use both as a way into a harder question — why corporal punishment is still defended in Black households when we would call the same actions abuse if they happened to anyone else.
From there they get into the real difference between discipline and abuse, how fear-based parenting breeds resentment instead of respect, and the generational cycle that repeats because “I turned out fine” is doing a lot of heavy lifting. They talk about Black masculinity, emotional shutdown, and what it does to a child’s sense of safety when the person who is supposed to protect them is also the person they are most afraid of.
Key Takeaways
A few things worth sitting with. Discipline is supposed to teach; abuse just conditions fear — and the line between them is whether a child actually learns something or only learns to be afraid. Corporal punishment is one of the last forms of violence many people will still defend out loud. Fear-based parenting tends to grow resentment, avoidance, and adults who never learned how to handle conflict in a healthy way. Breaking the cycle starts with being honest about what was harmful, instead of defending it just because we survived it.
Watch the Episode
Watch the full conversation on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EbxFh3RLOZU
Episode Transcript
The full conversation, lightly auto-transcribed for readers and search:
Sir. Yeah. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Yeah. So, don’t call the phone. Don’t message me the Instagram. And you won’t see him at school. I want to continue this conversation of child rearing and life. Elgen was kind enough to send a video to us — an Instagram video of a father “disciplining” his child on the gram. A little backstory: this father found out that his young pre-teen son had been smoking and being disrespectful to his mother. He found that out and he felt that the way to get his son to change his behavior, and to never do those things again, was to record himself beating him and put it on Instagram Live.
That is just the opening. Watch or listen to the full episode above for everything Big O, Big El, and Krush get into on discipline, abuse, and breaking the cycle.
Keep It In The Black
New here? Become Family to support the show and get closer to the conversation. Want more? Browse all episodes, or keep going with Kohen Wiley: Police Kill a 1-Year-Old in Senatobia, MS Over a Shoplifting Call.
